Case No. 06 · Performance reporting
Simulated caseNOMI
More traffic, fewer sales: finding where it broke, and which creative earned its budget.
I. The brief
NOMI raised its paid media spend and got many more landing page visits. But purchases and revenue went down. My task was to find where performance weakened, and which creative directions deserved the budget.
| Metric | August | September |
|---|---|---|
| Spend | €1,200 | €1,500 |
| Landing page views | 4,400 | 6,500 |
| Add to cart | 660 | 650 |
| Purchases | 240 | 232 |
| Revenue | €18,000 | €17,400 |
| Landing page view to add to cart | 15% | 10% |
II. Audience insight
Judge creative against the outcome it is meant to influence, not traffic volume alone.
The biggest drop came before add to cart: from 15% to 10% of landing page views (simulated). Later stages held steady. Add to cart to checkout moved from 59% to 56%, and checkout to purchase from 61% to 63%.
The extra traffic did not turn into stronger sales.
III. Strategy
I worked through the report in a fixed order, from the business result down to a recommendation.
- Business result
- Efficiency
- Funnel
- Creative breakdown
- Finding
- Hypothesis
- Recommendation
IV. Execution
| Creative | CPA | ROAS |
|---|---|---|
| City Routine, lifestyle Reel | €9.45 | 7.9× |
| Product Details, carousel | €4.38 | 17.1× |
| Everyday Use, UGC-style video | €5.63 | 13.3× |
Product Details had the strongest cost per purchase and return on ad spend, followed by Everyday Use. City Routine drove traffic, but bought purchases less efficiently.
V. Results and learnings
4 euros 38
Cost per purchase for Product Details, against €9.45 for City Routine. Simulated.
- Return
- 17.1× ROAS, against 7.9× for City Routine.
- Why it mattered
- Product-led and real-use creative fit the sales objective better.
Simulated data, modelled to show method. Not a reported client result.
Recommendations
- Prioritise product-detail and everyday-use variations for the purchase objective.
- Reallocate within the existing budget before increasing total spend.
- Test a revised lifestyle Reel with clearer product benefits, rather than dropping the whole format.
What I learned
A traffic-driving creative can still be the wrong one for a sales goal. Each format needs its own measure.